Let the Art begin!

[koolies54]

I personaly prefer 1 because I'm used to that type of bubbles.

[SupSuper]

I'm partial to 1 since rounded bubbles are a standard and look smoother.

[Alien King]

3.

1 just looks too common and 2 looks to indecisive.

[Paul.Power]

2. Has a more hand-made look.

[Metal Alex]

I'll have to pick 2. Not round, not square, good balance.

[Melon]

I honestly don't like number 2 and prefer number 3. I think number 2 just looks a bit scribbly. I actually dislike the drawn-by-hand look for speech bubbles myself. Have to agree with Vader that ellipse bubbles take up too much room, I found that out the hard way in my last comic.

[Plasma]

I found that out the hard way in my last comic.
You can remember that far back?


:p

[GrimOswald]

Is this the part where somebody says "Oh snap?" Wait, what is that you say? We do not do that for Plasma? Okay then. :cool:

As for the speech bubbles, I admit to being a fan of the good old fashioned round ones in number 1, but can understand that they do take up a fair bit of space. Out of the other two, I prefer 3. 2 is sort of a good idea, but just comes out looking a bit weird to me.

[Shadowmoon]

I prefer 3.

2 just doesn't stand out to me- it looks unusual.

[Error404]

Ok... what i take from all this is that there isn't a consensus. Each one of you seems to like a specific one for a specific reason. Hence, the best thing i can do is just go along with the one that i find most suit at the time, since it'll probably please just 1/3 of you. :p

Thanks for all the feedback! :D

[MtlAngelus]

Ok... what i take from all this is that there isn't a consensus. Each one of you seems to like a specific one for a specific reason. Hence, the best thing i can do is just go along with the one that i find most suit at the time, since it'll probably please just 1/3 of you. :p

Thanks for all the feedback! :D

No, 2 is better. As that was said by me, you can be guaranteed that you'll be pleasing the most important 1/3 of the bunch. :cool:

[Akuryou13]

No, 2 is better. As that was said by me, you can be guaranteed that you'll be pleasing the most important 1/3 of the bunch. :cool:he is very obviously correct :cool: